As you prepare for your new bundle of fluff, you’ll notice that an almost overwhelming amount of chews exist. What are the different types of chews, which ones should you buy for your new puppy, and when do you give her the different ones?Remember, for the safety of your dog, you should always supervise chew sessions.
There are 3 broad categories of chews and there can be some overlap between the categories. Those 3 main groups are: long lasting (high value) chews, medium lasting (medium value) chews, and short lasting (high value) chews. I’ll discuss long lasting and high value chews first and then touch on medium lasting at the end.
1. long lasting, lower value chews
Like toddlers, puppies explore the world with their mouths. Plus, until about 6 months of age when those adult teeth finish coming in, puppies are experiencing teething, which means that their mouths hurt. Chewing comes with the territory. Rather than punishing your puppy for chewing, encourage her to chew on the right things. It’s good to have a variety of chews lying around so your puppy can get that necessary chewing out by chewing things you want her to chew… and instead of chewing on your favorite pair of shoes!
There are two categories of long lasting chews: natural (aka animal product) chews and synthetic (aka nylon) chews.
Examples of long lasting natural chews:
- Split elk antlers (quarter split are good for tiny puppies)
- Water buffalo horns
- Hooves
We get our split elk antlers from Ridgerunner Antlers. I like that their antlers are collected from the ground when the elk shed them naturally. We purchase water buffalo horns and hooves from a local feed store. All are available on Amazon as well. Natural chews have some nutritional benefit.
Examples of long lasting synthetic chews:
Both Benebone and Nylabone make long lasting dog chews out of nylon. Both companies make their products in the USA. Their bones are made in a variety of shapes, sizes, and flavors. We find that our dogs usually prefer natural long lasting chew options, but will also gnaw on synthetic ones as they’re relaxing around the house in the evenings. Synthetic chews do not have nutritional benefit.
Some adult dogs love to curl up and relax with a good chew in the evenings. They appreciate having a few long lasting chews lying around, just as you might appreciate having the choice between a few good books before bed. Other adult dogs aren’t huge fans of chews. They’d prefer a good old fashion tennis ball over a chew any day. And that’s okay. We love that each dog is unique and has her own preferences.
2. high value, short lasting dog chews
It’s great to have some high value chews on hand for when your puppy is participating in daytime crate time. Think of these as puppy candy. Your dog will be super excited for a high value chew, will be completely obsessed with the chew until she finishes it, and will not be happy if you take it away from her prematurely. These high value chews won’t last long. She will power through them with determination. Don’t give your puppy a high value chew in a common area where someone (child or animal) might accidentally steal her treasured “lollipop.” Instead, use high value chews to create positive experiences for daytime crating.
Some examples of high value dog chews include: bully sticks, turkey tendons, pig ears, and so forth. Nature Gnaws makes a variety pack where you can try a number of different chews to learn what your best friend likes best and also learn which chews occupy her the longest. You may find that your dog devours certain high value chews in less than 2 minutes flat while others provide her with 20 minutes of chewing delight. None of them will last long, but all of them will be thoroughly enjoyed.
3. medium lasting, medium value dog chews
Some chew options aren’t quite as exciting as the high value options but are still well loved by dogs. Some dogs may finish them in one day while other dogs may chew the intermittently over the course of a week or so. Medium lasting chews a good option for giving to your puppy while you’re making dinner, participating in a video call for work, or providing your puppy with alone time in her play yard (again, always supervise your puppy when she has a chew). Medium lasting chews will keep her busy, but she won’t be quite as obsessed with them as the high value chews. Some examples of medium lasting chews include: yak chews (made from yak cheese) and beef trachea,


